Fairy Tale Anthologies
I'm currently in a storytelling class where I learn to tell tales without using a book. Terrifying, right? One of our major responsibilities is to read as many story collections as possible to find stories that appeal to us. As Randi well knows, I dislike most of what I read, so this is really taking some digging. My first row reviews the anthologies I liked and the second shows anthologies that didn't appeal to me for one reason or another. Expect another similar post later in the month because I just brought home another stack of these, lol.
p.s. I don't know why the covers of these are so tragic. Most of them are pretty old, but that hardly explains the hideousness of some of them.
Favorites
The Troll with No Heart in His Body, by Lise Lunge-Larsen.
This was my first and favorite collection. There is something about Norway that just screams old magic to me. This collection of troll stories includes all my favorites and some I'd never heard before. It contains just the right amount of frightening imagery without getting too adult. I also love how most of these are trickster tales. My very favorite tale? The Eating Competition!
Old Peter's Russian Tales, by Arthur Ransome.
Russia is another of my favorite locations for fairy tales. I like cold climates and lots of landscape atmosphere. Having just read the Snow Child, I was delighted to find "Little Daughter of the Snow". In the end, this is the one I decided to tell for my first class performance. Wish me luck!
Ready-To-Tell Tales: Sure-Fire Stories from America's Favorite Storytellers, by David Holt.
I'm still in the middle of this collection, containing both traditional and authored tales, tailored by some of the best known storytellers with bio information on each of them. Favorites include Godmother Death, The Black Prince, and Urishima Taro. Honestly, though, I'd feel comfortable telling any of these and I suppose that is the point lol. I kind of want to buy it.
Multicultural Folktales: Stories to Tell Young Children, by Judy Sierra.
I love how this marvelous collection offers felt board ideas as well as providing sanitized versions of folk tales and rhymes appropriate for the 3-5 crowd. My favorite story was a tie between the Stonecutter and Stone Soup.
Least Favorites
English Fairy Tales, by Joseph Jacobs
The compiler notes in the back that these versions of fairy tales were often overlooked when face with the smoother, more romantic French adaptations. I could see why....these were gritty and without much appeal or charm for me.
The People Could Fly, by Virginia Hamilton
I really wanted to like this one, but the structure of the stories fell flat for me. I felt like they built up dramatic tension and then rushed the endings and completely left out any kind of satisfying conclusions for most of them. I also had trouble with the dialect.
The Wonder Clock, by Howard Pyle
These tales felt like endless repetitions of the same elements without satisfying conclusions or justice and were too gritty for the age group I think they best fit. Many of them seem like they may have other versions or adaptations that I would like better and have been streamlined.
Mightier Than the Sword, by Jane Yolen.
Most of these just didn't catch my attention. They may have more appeal to boys. I did enjoy the Magic brocade immensely, however.